Categories
Uncategorized

Normalising and embracing childlessness in women

No part of this website, including the blog content may be copied, duplicated or reproduced in any manner without the author’s permission.

 

Any information, materials, and opinions on this blog do not constitute therapy or professional advice. If you need professional help, please contact a qualified mental health practitioner.

Normalising and embracing childlessness in women

ln a world that is fast changing, the family structures, as well as relationship frames are also changing. Traditionally a family as a concept was made up of a father (man) who is the breadwinner, a mother (woman) who is the child rarer, and children raised by two parents.

Image

Women typically stayed at home and reared the children, until they started rearing their own grandchildren. Women were primed to be the mothers, homekeepers, and family caregivers. The industrial revolution was indeed a paradigm shift which was defined by women leaving their culturally assigned roles of unpaid housework, into paid employment, which some will consider the beginning of feminism.

In contrast, men have always enjoyed the more superior role of being the provider, and naturally the head of the family- modern society still emulates similar dynamics. For our ancestors who were hunter-gatherers, men went to do the hunting, while women did the cooking of the catch. Despite the more recent shifts in gender roles, women have largely remained the carers, while men are the providers. These gender disparities create implicit power imbalances between men and women.

Patriarchy is a societal system which stems from the very notion that men are the rulers, and women are the ones to be ruled.  Interesting to note is the etymology of the word patriarchy, which is an English word coined from the Greek word “patriarkhes”, which means “the rule of the father”.

Changes to the family unit as well as the relationship frame in contemporary times mean we now have families made up of two men or two women in a same-sex relationship, raising their children. Advancement in the medical world means some same-sex couples can have biological children and raise them in the context of a same-sex parental home and family unit – for example, Sir Elton John.

There are families made up of two partners who are either married or unmarried and a pet. Other families are made up of two partners raising stepchildren, adoptive children, or foster children. Partners who choose to be childless can still identify themselves as a family, while individuals who are not in relationships and choose to be childless, can have what they consider their “chosen families”. These deviations from the traditional family and relationship frame made up of a father, mother, and their biological children need to be highlighted.


Voluntary and involuntary childlessness

As a therapist who has worked extensively with women who are childless by choice or due to fertility issues, I have become aware of the difference in the trajectory these women take in their journeys to childlessness and the associated emotional vicissitudes.

We tend to take the ability to conceive and gestate a live baby for granted, as it comes easy and spontaneously for some. However, many women do suffer from complex fertility issues which leaves them incapable of conceiving or gestating. In contrast, some women make a conscious decision at some point in their lives not to have children, and they never make any attempts to try. Although the outcomes are the same between women who voluntarily don’t have children and those who do so involuntarily, the difference between these two camps is the notion of choice.

Not wanting something because you are not interested in it, is different to wanting it and being denied. The woman who made the choice not to have children will have a very different experience from the one who did not make a choice and tried without success. This means involuntary childlessness, is encumbered by a sense of loss and grief and mourning for what could have been – a child, a family with children, and coming to terms with the reality.

Women who became childless by choice don’t tend to experience grief and loss as the decision not to have children is made consciously. They would have thought through and worked through it. This important distinction is significant as it helps us consider how we approach childlessness, and how we relate to childless individuals. I notice that in my using the the word child-less, less implies a lack! Childfree is more appropriate; however, I will stick to childless.


Some of the reasons why women may be childless

Women’s identities in society have changed over time. One of the ways that women are fighting patriarchy is by holding the same positions in their careers, and in jobs traditionally held by men. Gender roles have changed. There are now stay-at-home dads, female CEOs, wives who are breadwinners etc. We have even seen female presidents, and vice presidents which highlights some of the changes. What has not changed is that only women can carry a pregnancy and mother.

1. Career focus

For career-driven women, there is often a tension between their career and child-rearing, starting a family. It is often the case that the fertility window gets narrower as their careers are at their peak. Pausing one’s career to start having children can indeed be a big impingement on one’s career that they would have worked hard to achieve.

It’s more natural and sensible for these women to make the decision to pursue their careers, and put off having any children. This choice aligns with their lifestyle, values, and trajectory in life. It is a decision that many women tend not to regret, as their decisions it out of choice.

2. Personal choice

Some women just make the decision from very early on in their lives, or at some point in their lives that they do not want to have children. This may be because they want to enjoy their independence, and not have to hold the responsibility of raising a child. Some radical feminists consider having children as a way society uses women as childbearing vessels and child-rearing tools. One of the ways of fighting patriarchy is by claiming the right to their bodies (womb) and how they use it.

3. Early trauma

Some women would have experienced early trauma in their own childhood, and becoming parents is something that they naturally become averse to. Adversity in childhood, such as emotional neglect, abuse, witnessing parental conflict, or discordant parental relationships informs their decision to not have children.

They may be aware of the lack of inner resources to parent due to their own deficits and, therefore, choose not to have children. Some of these women may not be conscious of how the past trauma informs their decision-making, which comes to light when they start therapy.

4. Fertility issues

A huge number of women who are childless are people who had wanted to have children and were not successful due to fertility issues. Gynaecological health issues are widespread with millions of women diagnosed with fibroids, endometriosis, polycystic ovarian syndrome etc.

These women will experience complexities in their attempts to conceive, which can be very traumatic and emotionally wounding. These women’s childlessness and trajectory in life are very different to those who voluntarily choose not to have children.

5. Socio, economic, political

The socio, economic, and political climate is very unstable now. This drives some women to become reticent about bringing children into a world with so much volatility. The rising cost of living, crime, safety threats, and the political quagmire is something that not only affects us now but future generations.

For some, they would not want to rear children in a world that is unsafe and turbulent, therefore shaping their decisions not to have children. I have heard women who choose not to have children in respect of climate change, and the world becoming overpopulated, which is a potent reason.


Societal attitudes towards childlessness

There remains a lot of stigma, shame, and negative attitudes towards women who are childless, whether voluntarily, or involuntarily. No one should go around declaring why they are childless. Society never really considers the reasons for it – the tragic stories behind some of these childless women, which include fertility problems, childhood trauma etc.

Voluntary childlessness is a personal decision and choice one makes; however, society still tends to treat voluntary childlessness as something selfish and irresponsible. Women who choose to be child-free do not have to declare their reasons for it; it is perfectly within their rights to do so. Yet they are made to feel that they have to explain themselves and they have done something immoral.

Although this shaming is common in most cultures, certain cultures tend to treat childless women more harshly than others – for example, the Black and Asian cultures. In these communities, by a certain age, women are mandated to be in marriage with a husband and children. This curtails their careers, and any other life plans these women may have. Without fulfilling this family obligation, one is met with a lot of contempt and condemnation, as they are seen as not following the family values. Some of these women unconsciously rebel by never having children or getting married. This is also their way of claiming their autonomy over their lives and bodies.

While not having a child is a personal decision, from the stories l have heard, it is often met with a lot of antipathy, scorn, pity and judgement from family and friends. Typically, family and friends tend to look down on the child-free person simply because they are childless.

Direct or indirect questions tend to be asked about why one is not a parent “yet”. At times it’s sarcasm. Family gatherings become a source of stress and anxiety as these environments breed these antisocial and pernicious enquiries. This behaviour and line of questioning is inappropriate as one’s decision not to have children is indeed a personal one.

When you pity someone, you are inadvertently looking down on them, casting your shadow on them. Pity is something that most women who are childless feel from others. They are seen as misfits, and people who have failed in some way, no matter how successful they are in other areas of their lives. This does indeed impact the mental health of people who legitimately have reasons not to have children – out of choice or through circumstances – they are judged by societal standards. These attitudes are even more harmful to women who may have wanted children and failed due to fertility issues.


Self-care tips for childless women

1. For the childless woman, it’s important to create boundaries with others who may ask personal questions about your decision not to have children. You don’t have to explain your decisions to anyone, and you don’t owe them an explanation of your decision.

2. Family members and friends, if you are around somebody who is childless do not always ask personal questions about their decisions or put your judgement on their decisions. Having a child is not a sign of success, nor is choosing to be child-free a failure.

3. Instead of judging others for what you consider a failure, be curious and learn to appreciate their own decisions and choices, without casting your own views. Some women’s stories are those of trauma – when you open yourself up to the understanding that our motivations are shaped by our life foundations, we can have more empathy and compassion instead of judgements.

4. For women who did not volunteer to be child-free, but couldn’t due to circumstances, it’s important to consider this as a loss of what could’ve been. Every loss is followed by grief; it is paramount that one works through that grief and comes to a place of acceptance. Without doing that, seeing other families with children will always be triggering, as there is a reminder of what could have been – a wound that is not healed. Also being asked questions about why one does not have children also becomes very painful if the wound is sore.

5. For women who were not able to conceive naturally, consider adoption, or fostering. There are many children out there who need love and a safe home. Being a loving and nurturing parent who can provide them with a warm loving environment will change their world. And it will change yours too.

6. In general let’s view childlessness as a normal experience, not an aberration that invites scrutiny. Women have the right to make decisions about their bodies and their lives.

Categories
Uncategorized

A Beautiful Poem – Do Not Love Half Lovers- by Khalil Gibran

A Beautiful Poem- Do Not Love Half Lovers- by Khalil Gibran

Here is a beautiful  poem to help you start your week in a gentle manner, as  we draw closer to the Easter break- hope it is a break for you. May the warmer spring weather reflect the warmth in your heart, and that of others around you.
Wishing you a new week, and a new season of heart opening, in which you can live more authentically, and live from the heart.
The theme of this poem is life, love, courage, authenticity, and whatever resonates with you…

Do not love half lovers

Do not love half lovers
Do not entertain half  friends
Do not indulge in work of the half talented
Do not live half a life,  and do not die a half death
If you choose silence, then be silent
When you speak, do so until you’re finished
And do not silence yourself to say something
And do not speak to be silent
If you accept, then express it bluntly
Do not  mask it
If you refuse then be clear about it, for an ambiguous refusal is but a weak acceptance
Do not accept half a solution
Do not believe half truths
Do not dream half a dream
Do not fantasise about half hopes
Half  a drink will not quench your thirst
Half  a meal will not satiate your hunger
Half the way will not get you nowhere
Half an idea will bear you no results
Your other half is not the one you love
It  is you in another time yet in the same space
It is you when you are not
Half a life is a life you didn’t live
A word you haven’t said
A smile  you postponed
A love  you have not had
A friend you didn’t know
To reach and to not arrive
Work and not work
Attend, only  to be absent
What makes you stranger to them closest to you
And they are strangers to you
The half is a mere moment of inability
But you  are able, for you are not half a being
You are a whole that exist to live life
Not half a life
Khalil Gibran
Image Credit to Jared Rice- Unsplash
Categories
Uncategorized

Self-care tips for those who are unable to access therapy

COPYRIGHT CITY SANCTUARY THERAPY

No part of this website, including the blog content may be copied, duplicated or reproduced in any manner without the author’s permission.

 

Any information, materials, and opinions on this blog do not constitute therapy or professional advice. If you need professional help, please contact a qualified mental health practitioner.

Self-care tips for those who are unable to access therapy

Accessing therapy, and the notion of going to therapy is no longer shunned at, which is progressive. However, many people remain unable to access therapy due to various reasons. Nonetheless, we do need to find ways of cultivating robust mental health and practising habits that support both our physical and mental well-being.

Image

Why people may not be able to access therapy

Despite going to therapy being an act of courage in itself, many people who are keen to access therapy aren’t always able to. Here are some reasons why people may be unable to access therapy.

Cost

Therapy is not cheap, and many people have been excluded from benefiting from therapy due to cost. There aren’t many therapists or services offering low-cost fees. For some, the low-cost rate is still a huge financial sacrifice that they cannot meet. This leaves a certain group of people who could benefit from therapy excluded.

Stigma

As a society, there is a lot of stigma around mental health and therapy, leaving some feeling ashamed to seek therapy. This is a bigger issue in the minoritised communities, where therapy is taboo. We live in a world where people are meant to be “strong” and “pick themselves up” which means accessing therapy is viewed as a sign of weakness.

Based on my experience in the NHS, many young people access mental health support when they have severely deteriorated, and their families play a part in concealing their mental health challenges from society due to shame and stigma. This is an even bigger problem in minoritised communities. This means that their treatment outcomes are poor as they miss out on receiving treatment during the onset of their mental health challenges. Accessing therapy early and seeking help before the mental health challenges increase could indeed mitigate the deterioration.

Lack of awareness

Some people may not be aware of the benefits of therapy. They may not have an understanding of mental health and what therapy is. There are some communities and cultures that do not believe in therapy. They view therapy as a white middle-class invention, and an indulgent, with no value to them. This notion is reinforced by the fact that therapy is inherently a white middle-class concept and is practised by predominantly white therapists. Only in recent years, more and more people from minoritised backgrounds are beginning to have a grasp of what therapy is, and accessing it.

Poor representation

Many people are deterred from accessing therapy as they are unable to determine how to find a therapist that is a good fit for them. While this is an issue for anyone accessing therapy, it is even bigger a problem for people from minoritised backgrounds due to the lack of representation from people of their own backgrounds. The argument around therapist-client fit is never resolved as the relationship between therapist and client is key, regardless of their race, colour, class and culture.

However, it is true that many clients find it easy to talk to therapists who are from a similar cultural, racial, or class background as there are familiar references that do not need explaining. This is a real issue for people accessing therapy, which needs to be considered.

Fear of vulnerability and judgment

Therapy can make one feel exposed and vulnerable in many ways. The idea of having such an intimate relationship with someone with whom you get to tell all your secrets, and reveal shameful aspects of yourself can be daunting. The fact that therapy creates a power imbalance – as the therapist does not tell their clients their own issues, becomes even more unbearable for people accessing therapy.

Fear of judgement is a real issue, especially for people who may have had a lot of trauma, or people involved in behaviours that may be considered immoral. While therapy is not a space for judgment, this does indeed become a deterrent. Being vulnerable is not something that we all embrace, more so in the presence of an unfamiliar other. There needs to be a relationship and safety. Fear of vulnerability does indeed become a big limitation for many.

Denial

Denial is a defence against accepting the reality, however, it doesn’t make the problem go away. Some individuals may be in denial about their problems, no matter how big they are and think that they do not need therapy. This is indeed detrimental in the long term as what starts as a small issue can develop into a bigger problem if not addressed at the right time.

Time constraints

Despite therapy now being available online, which makes it easier to access, some people just don’t have the time to attend therapy. This is mainly for people in full-time employment with families. Some people do not find online therapy helpful to them as It may feel impersonal to them. While this is a subjective feeling, they miss the opportunity of doing therapy as they cannot engage online and don’t have the time for in-person sessions.

Previous negative experiences

I have encountered many people who have had negative experiences with therapists in the past, leading them to be aversive to therapy. While the experience may be related to a particular therapist, it clouds their judgment on therapy as  a whole.


Self-care tips

With these deterrents in mind it is important that we identify ways in which people can take care of themselves and cultivate their mental well-being without going to therapy.  If you are unable to access therapy, here are some useful self-care tips and why they are important.

Healthy diet

A healthy diet includes all the nutrients the body requires- protein, carbohydrates, healthy fats, water, iron, etc. The body and mind an intricately linked. Having a healthy diet translates into a robust immune system, healthy skin, optimal energy levels, a healthy digestive system, and regulated chemical balance. Cooking yourself a good healthy meal can also be a good form of self-care and a mastery activity which bolsters our sense of well-being.

Stress management

Stress is one of the key causes of poor mental health – chronic stress can lead to burnout. Stress increases the chances of developing anxiety, depression, insomnia, high blood pressure, migraines and fatigue. Chronic exposure to the stress hormone cortisol and adrenalin has been linked to other physical health conditions such as autoimmune disorders and hypertension. It is vital that you find ways to combat stress and give yourself time to rest. Planning your tasks in manageable chunks, and approaching the tasks in a graded manner will help you lower your stress levels.

Routine

Having a routine is hugely significant in giving your body and mind a rhythm that it can follow. Just like a baby that needs a feeding, sleep, and playtime routine, our bodies and minds respond well to routine and some kind of structure – repetition – to help regulate itself. Not having a routine leaves one in a state of dysregulation and also makes it difficult to self-regulate, something that our bodies are capable of doing for us naturally.

Sleep hygiene

Sleep is a key component of well-being. Sleep is a necessity, and it is good quality sleep that matters the most. Sleep allows our bodies and minds to naturally repair themselves, heal and reset. Sleep is also essential for emotional processing something that we do in our dreams. Sleep hygiene means engaging in habits that promote sleep as a natural process -this aligns with routine. Sleep hygiene may mean things like getting rid of gadgets, not speaking to friends on the phone late at night, getting into bed early, and not drinking coffee, alcohol or other stimulants after a certain time of the day.

Personal hygiene and self-care

The external world is typically a reflection of our internal world. You are more likely to feel good after a shower and wearing your best clothes than you do walking around unshowered, unkempt and in dirty clothes. The notion of your body being your temple is helpful here in highlighting the significance of taking care of your body, which will also feed back to your mind. Self-care is a mastery activity which can evoke the body’s natural opiates – endorphins, our feel-good hormones.

Treatment of underlying physical health issues

It is hugely significant to have checkups with your GP and dentist. Many people have or suspect they may have some health problems that they do not address in time. These may be impacting their mental health and treating the underlying condition translates into enhanced mental health.

Community and positive relationships

No man’s land is an Island! We need others, we are social beings. Having positive relationships with others around us and fostering a community is key to positive mental health. Isolation and loneliness can make small problems look even bigger – the experience of being “psychically” held by others is profoundly powerful and its healing mechanisms are what made our ancestors thrive as groups of people.

Journaling and personal reflections

Journaling is a powerful way of processing. Putting one’s personal reflections, thoughts and feelings is hugely significant and therapeutic. Journaling is something that is done subjectively, and no one has to read, judge or mark what you have written. Being able to have an honest appraisal of oneself through journaling can indeed lead to an autonomous change in behaviours and attitudes that may be problematic in one’s life.

Affirmations

Affirmations are a powerful way of expressing self-love and self-validation. We are so quick to seek validation, compliments, and words of affirmation from others, yet this is something we should be giving ourselves. We cannot fully love others if we do not love ourselves. Self-love starts with affirming yourself, reminding yourself of all the qualities that you embody and what you want to see manifest out of that.

Affirmations are a love language  “words of affirmations” and they go along with other love languages like quality time. If you affirm yourself you are likely to treat yourself with kindness and compassion and become less critical. Write a list of affirmations and use them daily when you wake up.

Identifying your values

Values are key to our sense of self and well-being. They guide how we live our lives and what matters to us. When we live a value-led life, we are likely to feel purposeful, and a sense of wholesomeness, which translates to positive mental health. Many a time, our suffering stems from leading a valueless life which makes life empty, defeated and as if you are a passenger in your own life.

Write down your values and identify how your current life aligns with your values. Note what us is you can do/change to get yourself back to living a value-led life. This can be a painful process as it may mean letting go of certain relationships and habits we have engaged with which misalign, or are in conflict with our values.

Image Credit to Thabita Turner-Unsplash

Categories
Uncategorized

Understanding the significance of sleep in mental well-being

COPYRIGHT CITY SANCTUARY THERAPY

No part of this website, including the blog content may be copied, duplicated or reproduced in any manner without the author’s permission.

Any information, materials, and opinions on this blog do not constitute therapy or professional advice. If you need professional help, please contact a qualified mental health practitioner.

Dr Joyline Gozho, Adult Psychotherapist (Individual & Couples) FPC, UKCP, NCPS

Despite the plethora of pro-health initiatives driven by social media, l have become aware that mental health and wellbeing practitioners do not give sleep the same level of attention and significance as they do to having a healthy diet, exercise, and hydration. Sleep is a key component of one’s well-being; any disturbances impact our physical, mental, and psychological well-being.

Image

Despite having evolved over a millennium, we are innately cavemen; our bodies and minds are not primed to deal with the heightened level of stimulation of the present day. Sleep is therefore even more important to reset, restore, and replenish our minds and bodies as intimately linked systems. Our ancestors lived in the jungle and didn’t have electricity, electronic gadgets, and the level of noise pollution we deal with. While they had their hunter-gatherer problems, they didn’t have to strive in the way that we do as a result of living in a capitalist society focused on productivity.

We live in a society where sleep problems are normalised, and no longer seen as insidious, and harmful yet they are. The dangers of lack of sleep cannot be underestimated as they are real. More recently, l have become aware that one can survive longer without food than they can do without sleep!

Both in my personal and professional life, l have encountered countless people who live on average 4 hours of sleep each night due to the nature of their jobs and careers. If there have deadlines etc, these hours could be even significantly less. I have encountered a highly successful man surviving on 4 hours of sleep working with colleagues in different time zones who fell asleep on the stairs as he couldn’t get himself to his bedroom; and a woman who fell asleep on the tube on the way her way to work, and woke up miles away from her destination. These are not isolated stories; they may sound funny, but looking closely, there is real sadness in how these people push themselves beyond capacity, without sleep, and their bodies just shut down.

On the contrary, lack of sleep makes one unproductive altogether, due to brain fogginess, tiredness, lethargy, reduced attention span, inability to retain information, and fatigue that is caused. Irritability and emotional sensitivity are some of the signs of poor sleep or a lack of sufficient sleep, which can lead to more complex mental and physical health problems. These behavioural and emotional changes can negatively impact interpersonal relationships.

Biological science suggests that the average amount of sleep for a healthy adult should be 7-8 hours; this is also dependent on several factors for example the level of daytime exertion, one’s physical health, etc. However, what’s crucial is the quality of sleep, not only the quantity. Work stress exacerbates poor sleep; I have met people who drag themselves to their office desk each morning powered by coffee or Red Bull- at times other narcotic stimulants as a way of coping with work stress which feeds into lack of sleep.

The human body and mind operate in the same way as a machine. It needs to be switched off, reoiled, serviced, and cleaned before it can be efficiently driven again, without causing you problems. If you keep pushing the machine without stopping it to do all the essential maintenance work, it collapses. Sleep helps our body and mind repair itself, recharge, replenish and reset. If you cannot give the body sufficient time to repair itself through sleep, it will fail.


Sleep as a psychosocial issue

Despite sleep problems being a complex that has roots in the social context, most people who visit GPs and other mental health practitioners such as psychiatrists are often diagnosed with insomnia, anxiety or depression (secondary to poor sleep) and prescribed hypnotics, antidepressants, antianxiety to help them sleep. This medical approach overlooks the problem which lies in the psychosocial – work stress and anxiety which lead to poor sleep. These are psychoactive medications which come with a whole host of unpleasant side effects, and one tends to become tolerant, needing higher doses. In therapy, it is important to address the root cause of sleep problems, address them as a psychosocial issue where adjustments can be made pragmatically, and also address the underlying “core beliefs” one may have created, which are typically around perfectionism and fear of failure.

CBT is a great model for addressing sleep problems as it gives the client both tools and psychoeducation. I wish some of these clients who end up medicated before could consider finding other ways they can minimise the work stress, and exercise sleep hygiene, so they can foster healthy sleep. Many a time there is a combination of stress and poor sleeping habits. Our minds work through repetition; if you stimulate your mind at night and it is used to being active instead of switching off, it will surely obey that command and you will find it difficult to find sleep at night. Many people who experience sleep disturbances or insomnia are hugely impacted by work-related stress. They often have demanding schedules and have the pressure to constantly be available which contributes to mental and physical arousal, making it difficult to asleep.

Contemporary life and stimulation

Our day-to-day life presents with so many mental and physical stimulations which naturally dysregulate the body from its natural homeostatic state, which contributes to poor sleep. Modern, fast-paced lifestyles are flooded with sources of stimulation, such as electronic devices, social media, work-related stress, and busy schedules, which do not allow for the body and mind to naturally regulate themselves. Electronic devices emit blue light that can suppress the production of melatonin, a hormone that regulates sleep-wake cycles. Some people end up being prescribed melatonin replacement (banned in the UK) as a way of replenishing their melatonin resources. However, as a side effect, this can also disrupt the natural sleep-wake rhythm and make it difficult to fall asleep.

Another issue that perpetuates sleep problems is the internet where there is constant access to information and communication through technology which creates a sense of urgency to catch up with the latest news. Fear of Missing Out (FOMO) is a savvy concept coined to describe the anxiety caused by the perpetual consumption of social media and the subsequent fear of missing out it creates. This is even more problematic for people who have busy lifestyles and only have the time to go on their social media at night when they get home. Some of the news one watches for example wars or any other distressing events around the world can also create anxiety, which heightens the body’s arousal even further, making it more difficult to sleep.

Sleep and the body’s regulatory system – window of the tolerance

When we are physically and mentally stimulated, we go into a state of hyperarousal (fight/flight) which is one of the automatic self-preservative modes (red zone) in response to real or perceived danger. When we are in the hyperarousal state, our bodies become dysregulated, and the parasympathetic nervous system produces stress hormone cortisol, and adrenalin in response to the need to fight or fight.

Along with this are physiological responses such as racing thoughts, heart racing, muscle tension, interruptions to the digestive system, and our minds becoming sharp and alert. One cannot fall asleep if they are in this state, as the danger alarm system is going off. Due to the arousal, one is likely to reach for their phone and watch TV which creates a vicious cycle. In order to be able to fall asleep, one needs to bring themselves back down into the state where they are calm and able to switch off.


Sleep as a normal mammalian process

All mammals sleep and some sleep longer than others. Humans need sleep too, and they cannot function optimally without good quality sleep. Babies sleep longer as it is necessary for their rapid growth and getting used to the environment outside the womb. Some babies experience sleep regression, which can be very traumatic for the parents to cope with, causing distress to both baby and mother. On the other end, older people tend to sleep more and for longer periods, as their bodies require more time to repair themselves. Sleep is innate, any disturbances to it will without doubt trigger other complex health issues- depression, anxiety, chronic fatigue, and other health problems. When we view sleep as a luxury, not a necessity, it undermines our health and innateness, which has foundations in sleep.

What happens when we sleep?

Sleep is not just a physical state of lying in a semi-conscious state. It is a mind-body experience where the mind is actively churning all the daytime material processing, and physiologically the body is repairing itself. While sleep hygiene is significant in developing healthy habits around sleep, what is even more important is understanding what happens during sleep, the significance of it, and how it aids to good mental health. It also helps us appraise the harmfulness of poor sleep, both physically and mentally.

A healthy sleep cycle has successive stages that are necessary for the body and mind’s ability to reset and restore itself.

Different stages of sleep:

  • Stage 1: Non-rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep is divided into three phases each representing a deeper level of sleep. This cycle repeats multiple times throughout the night, with REM sleep occurring more frequently in the later stages of sleep.
  • Stage 2: Rapid eye movement (REM).

Stage 1: Non-rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep

This is the transition stage between wakefulness and sleep. It is a light sleep stage where people may experience drifting thoughts and occasional muscle twitches. During the second stage, sleep gets deeper- the body temperature drops, the heart rate slows down, and brain activity decreases. This stage is also characterised by bursts of rapid brainwave activity.

The third stage of the non-rapid eye movement sleep is the deepest sleep stage, also known as slow-wave sleep (SWS). It is characterised by very slow brainwaves, and it is difficult to wake someone up from this stage of sleep. This crucial stage is where the body undergoes a restorative process such as tissue and organ repair and growth. People with sleep disturbances are less likely to experience this restorative sleep level, hence why they always feel tired, fatigued and lethargic.

Stage 2: Rapid eye movement (REM) sleep

This distinctive sleep stage is characterised by rapid eye movements, increased brain activity, and vivid dreaming as the brain is highly active. REM sleep is important for memory consolidation, learning, emotional regulation as well as emotional processing. When someone is struggling with a particular issue that may be emotionally burdening for them in their daily life (current or historic), it is in the REM sleep that the mind tries to process these emotions.

That’s why we tend to dream of things that may resonate with what we are experiencing or have experienced in life, although they may be distorted or ambiguous. During this stage, the body is typically paralyzed to prevent acting out dreams in a physical form. Another unique quality of REM sleep is that it is linked to creativity and problem-solving abilities. REM sleep is the quality sleep which is particularly beneficial to our mental and physical health. Lack of REM sleep or disrupted REM sleep patterns have been associated with mood disorders, anxiety, depression, chronic fatigue and other mental and physical health issues.

Sleep and dreaming

In the interpretation of dreams, Freud (1900) delved into dreams and the significance of sleep and dreaming as something that a healthy mind does, as according to him we dream to protect sleep and process. Freud viewed the capacity to dream as healthy, and dreaming as a way of using the psychic energy which is translated into images. He viewed dreaming as a manifestation of the unconscious, considering nightmares and other sleep disturbances as well as interruption of dreaming as a sign of psychopathology.

Freud viewed dreams as holding one’s wishes, desires, conflicts, and other aspects of ourselves we cannot readily make sense of in the conscious state. He considered dreaming as a state where our conscious, unconscious and subconscious, are porous, and there is an interaction between these three parts of our psyche and a consolidation of them. With this happening in the sleep state, repressed wishes, desires, and conflicts are to be found not only in the latent, but manifest material. For him, dreaming was “The royal road to the unconscious”. He considered dream interpretation a significant part of any psychotherapy that is intended to make the unconscious conscious. Although not backed by empirical evidence, Freud’s ideas on sleep and dreaming would fit the scientific explanation of what sleep is and how it is beneficial in emotional processing, problem-solving and creativity.


Ways of improving sleep

Poor sleep hygiene:

Irregular sleep schedules, excessive use of electronic devices before bed, a disruptive sleep environment, or consuming stimulating substances like caffeine or nicotine close to bedtime can all disrupt sleep and should be completely avoided. Have a sleep routine and engage in meditative exercise to regulate your body and allow it to rest.

Stress and anxiety:

High levels of stress or anxiety can make it difficult to fall asleep or stay asleep. Minimize stress in your day-to-day life and give yourself time to rest and replenish your internal resources. When you are less stressed and not anxious, your body is in the green zone of the WOT and you are likely to find sleep easily.

Medical conditions:

If your sleep problems are persistent despite how much you try to exercise sleep hygiene, make sure you get checked for certain medical conditions such as sleep apnoea, restless leg syndrome, or hormonal imbalances.

Mental health disorders:

Conditions like depression, anxiety disorders, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), or bipolar disorder can disrupt sleep patterns. If you tend to ruminate at night and find it difficult to sleep, there could be an unresolved issue that needs attention.

Medications, illicit substances and alcohol:

All these are psychoactive and they act on the brain which inhibits sleep. Certain medications, such as antidepressants, stimulants, or certain asthma medications, can affect sleep quality. Taking illicit substances recreationally or habitually can also cause sleep problems. Make sure your physician can evaluate your medication.

Poor sleep habits:

Engaging in activities that stimulate the mind or body close to bedtime, napping excessively during the day, and irregular sleep patterns can all contribute to poor sleep.

Environmental factors:

A noisy sleeping environment, uncomfortable bedding, extreme temperatures, or excessive light can all impact your ability to sleep and the overall quality of sleep.


It is important to establish healthy sleep habits and create a conducive sleep environment to counteract the overstimulation of present-day life and promote better sleep. This may involve creating a bedtime routine, limiting screen time before bed, managing stress levels, and prioritising self-care and relaxation.

Article Tags

Image
London SE1 & Milton Keynes MK15
Written by Dr Joyline Gozho, Adult Psychotherapist (Individual & Couples) FPC, UKCP, NCPS

Dr Joyline Gozho is an Adult Psychotherapist, Relationship Therapist, and Lecturer on a Psychotherapy course. She works with both individual and couples in private practice. She also runs relationship enrichment workshops with a particular focus on

Categories
Uncategorized

Emotions and crying: Embracing your full self through crying

COPYRIGHT CITY SANCTUARY THERAPY

No part of this website, including the blog content may be copied, duplicated or reproduced in any manner without the author’s permission.

Any information, materials, and opinions on this blog do not constitute therapy or professional advice. If you need professional help, please contact a qualified mental health practitioner.

Emotions and crying: Embracing your full self through crying

Through my experience as a therapist and mental health practitioner l have observed that the societal attitudes towards crying are replicated in the therapy room. It is time that this problem is unpacked and addressed.

Image

Although social attitudes towards crying vary greatly depending on cultural, societal, and individual factors, in Western society crying is seen as a sign of weakness and/or vulnerability. We have been socially conditioned to believe that certain things are good and bad, and we shouldn’t question why they are good or bad. We cannot always make any critical analysis of certain views, as it means deviating from the conventional opinions which always feel unsafe.

This is the case with crying, where there seem to be some implicit rules that forbid us from expressing emotions, and not crying in front of others as it is viewed as shameful and embarrassing. There is a lot of stigma around crying which also varies according to age, gender, and social status. Men are taught that to be masculine you must “toughen up” and not show emotions. The notions that “big boys don’t cry”, or “man up”, and for women, “it’s not cute to cry” and “crying makes you look silly” are embedded in our psyches.

Crying is often viewed as childish, a sign of immaturity, and juvenile because it is associated with babies. Babies cry a lot; because they cannot use language to express themselves or communicate their needs. Crying is also a fundamental part of the baby’s attachment behaviour, necessary for their psychological development.

The crying elicits a response in the caregiver which facilitates being taken care of. We know that in normal development, as babies get older and learn to use language, they tend to cry less. However, crying remains a fundamental part of our human make-up, in response to certain feelings and emotions such as upset, sadness, and hurt, and as a way of expressing emotional pain. It is therefore perfectly normal and healthy for adults to cry as an emotional expression when one is hurt, sad, upset and emotionally distressed.

Sadly, there remains a misconception that crying is anti-social, yet it is prosocial, driven by our innate drives, and the human part of us that emotes and seeks comfort. Crying remains an attachment-driven behaviour; when we cry, we invite others to attend to us and soothe us which fundamentally meets our attachment needs. The same process that happens in babies when they cry, it also happens in adults, and this is a perfectly normal human reaction.


Crying and the therapy room

I have learnt through my experience as a therapist, through interacting with other therapists, as well as from reading literature, that both male and female clients find it incredibly difficult to cry, or tend to apologise for crying in the therapy room if they do.

Therapists often have to remind some of their clients that they are human, it’s normal to cry, and normalise crying. This reminder often brings down the barrier to crying and enables the client to permit themselves to cry and allow a full expression of emotions. Suppressing emotions could be the reason why that individual may have ended up in therapy after all. In his book The Myth of Normal, Gabor Mate makes the link between the psychological and physical, highlighting that unprocessed emotions can manifest as psychic or physical pain and repressed emotions undermine the immune system.

I use the term “emotional constipation” to capture what happens when we suppress emotions. In the same way as unprocessed food (meals) causes physical constipation and tummy aches, unprocessed emotions also cause psychological constipation, which compacts our minds and causes us pain. The only way to process emotions is by allowing oneself to lean into them, as painful as it is, which will free one’s psychic space up, and create room for other emotions. Crying is a form of processing, and clearing up that psychic space.

Tears are pregnant with emotions, and we know that a good sob feels like an outpour of emotions and release. There are words embedded in those tears that should have been said, we should respect tears as a manifestation of the unspoken words.  Bearing the pain, and witnessing those tears in the therapy room, is a powerful and transformative experience, which is key to healing.

I often remind my clients that if they expect to sweat when they go to the gym, they should not shy away from sweating in the room; crying is a form of emotional sweating, and there is nothing wrong with it. Saying this is neither reassurance nor patronising; it is creating a human connection, and humanising myself as someone who emotes and does cry myself when the occasion arises.

Therapists are humans who are deeply emotionally moved by their clients’ stories and sometimes tear up. There is nothing wrong with that, as long as it’s not a matter of the client looking after the therapist who is clearly overwhelmed and emotionally flooded. Therapists have done many years of therapy and some still go to therapy. They do cry in their own therapy, and that makes them human.


Social status and personality

There is a perception that people of high status in society must remain stoic and not seen crying in public, as it is a sign of weakness and ineptitude. Although there is no direct message that crying is bad, modelling these defensive behaviours reinforces the notions that crying is anti-social, and a sign of weakness and perpetuates the negative attitudes towards crying. Many a time it is the parent, head of the family, or older sibling who is made to just carry on, no matter how much they are emotionally struggling and pretend everything is fine – “crying means l am weak, and l let everyone down”.

One’s personality and temperament is shaped by their unique experience growing up in their homes and the quality of care they received from their caregivers. Growing up in a home where crying is not permissible, or chastised, one internalises certain beliefs about crying and constructs “core beliefs” around crying. In adult life, this enforces the idea that crying is bad.

Core beliefs are conclusions about oneself based on life experiences. Core beliefs are fortified by rules for living which are standards in which self-worth can be measured, which supports the core belief. For example, one can have a core belief that “l am weak” and can build a rule for living that “l must not cry and remain stoic, otherwise l will be seen as weak”. These core beliefs are difficult to shake off or reframe particularly if they are supported by societal views, and modelled by people we look up to.


Crying and well-being

I am sure you can relate to the idea that “sometimes all l need is a good cry”. Crying can be cathartic, and lead to a release of emotions that cannot be accessed in any other way but a good sob!

The negative attitudes towards crying and full expression of emotions lead to suppressing emotions and hiding one’s true feelings. It also means we never learn to become emotionally literate as emotions are a big part of who we are which helps us understand what matters to us. They make life more meaningful and colourful, and crying is an expression of those emotions. Emotions make us want to act, and different emotions guide us towards different kinds of actions.

If you are watching a sad film or hearing a sad story, you are moved to tears – embrace it as it’s your emotions in action. The suppression of emotion is harmful as every emotion is valid. If emotions are suppressed, they will find a way to leak out – for example, unresolved grief/loss can manifest in depression, suppressed anger can manifest in depression or anger outbursts, and a traumatic event can lead to anxiety or PTSD symptoms.

In Gabor Mate’s book Myth of Normal, he highlights how unresolved trauma (suppressed emotions) can manifest in a physiological form, emphasising the need for emotional processing which may include crying. The same sentiment is echoed by Van de Kolk – The Body Keeps the Score – in his work on trauma addressing how trauma becomes embodied and translated into a psychological state.

By crying we are also able to soothe ourselves as crying releases oxytocin (love hormones and endorphins (natural painkillers), which support natural bonding. Bonding is a key element of our innate make-up as social beings. When we cry, we are likely to get attention from others who come forward to comfort and soothe us. This is a pro-survival skill which in many ways is linked to our desire to seek connection, comfort, and care from others. Crying can also make us feel calmer as one is likely to take in more deep breaths, balancing the oxygen-carbon dioxide ratio.


Dissociation

Dissociation is a state of emotional detachment from one’s thoughts and feelings which can lead to forgetting memories, periods in life, events, and experiences that would otherwise be readily accessible. Dissociation can happen on different levels – benign (zoning out) and more severe forms of dissociating which require professional treatment.

Dissociation develops as a defence mechanism against experiencing certain emotions which are deemed too painful or difficult at a young age, or in reaction to a traumatic event – for example, in the form of PTSD-related dissociation. When one dissociates, they do not experience any physical and emotional pain – they do not cry since they have no emotional reaction to the experience.

Dissociation is often a result of trauma – historic or acute. Trauma is not just what happened to you, for example, physical abuse, verbal abuse, sexual abuse, dictators, accidents, or loss, but also non-events such as the emotional deficit in not having an adult who is emotionally available to an infant who may be experiencing complex emotions.

Wilfred Bion (1962a) writes elegantly about the baby’s caregiver’s function of receiving the baby’s complex emotions, handling them, detoxifying them, making sense of them, and handing them back in a palatable form. Bion (1962a) termed this function containment, which is related to the baby projecting into the mother and the mother being affected and responding to these projections, a term called projective identification. Bion (1962b) emphasised the caregiver’s ability to turn the Beta elements (unprocessed and unmetabolised affective experiences) into Alpha elements which the infant can think about and make sense of.

The absence of an emotionally attuned caregiver leaves the infant unable to process complex emotions, which can lead to dissociation as a way of dealing with what is for the infant viewed as life-threatening. People who experience some form of disturbances in this parental function are likely to dissociate or struggle with availing themselves to their emotions. They are likely not to cry as they are not emotionally affected.


Crying as a normal human experience

Crying is indeed a natural and healthy expression of emotion. It is not simply a reflexive tear production, but an emotional tear production. Crying can be seen as a way to release stress, sadness, or frustration, and is often considered a normal response to certain life events or situations.

If we are more accepting that crying is not a sign of weakness, but simply being human, we are likely to experience secondary physical and mental health problems related to suppressing emotions. When we embrace crying, we can even encourage others to express their emotions through tears and be vulnerable with us without fear of judgement. People tend to feel more comfortable crying openly when they know their feelings are validated and they will not be judged for it.

As a society, we must eradicate the stigma attached to crying, particularly for men, who may be expected to display emotional stoicism and not show any signs of weakness. I believe this is why both addictions and suicide are high in men in comparison to women. Women should also be allowed to express their anger, and cry despite it being viewed as “not being ladylike” and crying seen as “silly”. Embracing these emotions and fully expressing them through crying is healthy.

Overall, it is important that we create an environment where people feel comfortable expressing their emotions authentically without shame, and fear of judgement. In the therapy room a big part of our work as therapists is enabling clients to develop an emotional vocabulary, to help them better understand their emotions, and to allow a full expression of emotions.

When we can be vulnerable with each other, we can process emotions that we otherwise suppress, leading to depression, anxiety, problem anger, and other physical health problems. This also translates to people not carrying so much emotional baggage and utilise therapy as their only way to learn about their emotions and process.


Benefits of crying

1. Stress relief

Crying can help to alleviate emotional and psychological stress. It provides an outlet for releasing built-up tension and pent-up emotions, which helps in reducing anxiety and promoting relaxation and overall well-being.

2. Emotional catharsis

Crying serves as a form of emotional release. It allows individuals to express and process their feelings, enabling them to gain a sense of relief and clarity. It can help in dealing with grief, hurt, sadness, anger, frustration, or any intense emotions.

3. Mood enhancement

Crying triggers the release of endorphins and other feel-good hormones in the brain, which can improve mood and provide a sense of soothing and comfort. Crying helps individuals feel better and experience a sense of emotional release and renewal. Oxytocin and endorphins released in crying are natural feel-good hormones which promote physical and mental well-being.

4. Social connection

Crying can foster social bonding, empathy and connection with others. When others witness someone crying, it often evokes compassion and support, leading to a sense of connection and understanding. This can strengthen relationships, provide emotional support and foster connections.

5. Physical benefits

Tears help to lubricate and cleanse the eyes, preventing dryness and irritation. Crying can also stimulate the parasympathetic nervous system, which helps to regulate heart rate and promote relaxation. Deep breathing in crying helps regulate the body and bring it back into a homeostatic state.


How to tune into your human self

1. When you are emotionally affected by something, reflect on how you are feeling. Gently lean into those feelings and cry if you feel like it. Distancing yourself emotionally or dismissing any emotionally impactful experiences will only make it harder for you to tune into your emotions and cry. This also means not fully emotionally processing the meaning of the event.

2. Learn the habit of confiding in someone you trust. We tend to find it easier to cry if we feel safe, not shamed or judged. If there is something you are finding difficult to deal with, call a friend you trust, or arrange to meet and confide in them. If there is a compulsion to cry, embrace it.

3. In your therapy – if you have found it difficult to cry, explore this with your therapist. Understanding the reasons behind our behaviours is key to remedying them. Also, allow yourself to be human in the therapy room and embrace what unfolds.

4. It is important to note that excessive or prolonged crying without relief may indicate an underlying issue, such as depression or chronic stress. If crying becomes overwhelming or interferes with daily functioning, see an accredited therapist or mental health practitioner as it could be a sign of deeper issues that need addressing.


References 

  • Bion, W. R. (1962a) Learning from experience. London: Karnac.
  • Bion W.R. (1962b). The psycho-analytic study of thinking. Int J Psycho-Anal 43: 306–10.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author. All articles published on Counselling Directory are reviewed by our editorial team.

Categories
Uncategorized

Coping with loneliness in the 21st Century

COPYRIGHT CITY SANCTUARY THERAPY

No part of this website, including the blog content may be copied, duplicated or reproduced in any manner without the author’s permission.

Any information, materials, and opinions on this blog do not constitute therapy or professional advice. If you need professional help, please contact a qualified mental health practitioner.

Coping with loneliness in the 21st Century

Image

So why do these technological and digital advancements matter so much? Aren’t we supposed to be celebrating, and feel even more connected; why then has loneliness become pervasive? The significance in letter writing, other non-digital connections and face to face interaction lies in the idea of being kept in mind; the intention and thoughtfulness behind the letter writing makes it profoundly special. So does the intention carve out time, leave everything behind, and visit someone.

What’s unique and particularly special is the effort to sit and write- putting one’s thoughts into written words, seal the letter in an envelope, stamp, and post it. Carving out time to visit someone or meet someone shows how much one cares and appreciates that person, in comparison to digital messaging from a distance. So how face to face interactions or letter writing any different to the instant text messaging, or interacting via Facebook, Instagram, or other digital interactions. These different channels of engaging are not the same, and they can never be the same.

Real connections are not digital. Digital connections can never replace real human connections in real time. 


Real connections and digital connections

We experienced a paradigm shift in the past few years; we now live in a digital era, pivoted by the Covid 19 pandemic, which propelled us into the digital world. There is no way back from the digital world, we must embrace what the use of technology brings- the good and the bad. We cannot however ignore the fact that despite these advancements, loneliness remains a societal issue that needs attention. While the digital world has enhanced our ability to connect en mase, it has also deduced the true and rich human connection we make through face-to-face interactions, or other non-digital contact, such as letters and face to face interactions.


What is loneliness?

Loneliness is a complex and distressing emotional state that arises when a person feels emotionally disconnected, or isolated from others. The irony is that one can have many people around them but still feels emotionally disconnected from them. Loneliness is a subjective feeling and an internal experience of being alone, even when surrounded by other people.

Loneliness can be characterized by feelings of sadness, emptiness, and a lack of social connection or meaningful relationships-hallmarks of depression and anxiety. Loneliness is not solely determined by the number of social interactions a person has, but rather the quality and depth of those interactions. In the case of people who have thousands and millions of followers of social media, it does not translate to them not feeling lonely, or having deeper connections.

Loneliness has a negative impact on mental, physical health, and ones self esteem as well as overall sense of self. Chronic loneliness can lead to increased risk of depression, anxiety, and other health problems. The risk is even higher when one feels lonely while going through challenging life situations.

The difference between loneliness and being alone

In his work with children, Psychiatrist and Psychanalyst Donald Winnicott (1958) exposited the difference of being alone and loneliness. He emphasised on the healthy state developed in the capacity to be alone, in which he indicated to be a sign of emotional maturity. I see this as expanding one’s window of tolerance, where one can subjectively bear a range of emotions without relying on external world for distraction, or to gain reassurance.

Being alone means one feels content in their own presence, without the need for stimulation or distraction from the external world, for example in having may friends in the digital world and not having any close relationships and connections. This means there are many people who are not alone, and surrounded by people, but feel very lonely- not alone externally, but feel very lonely internally. Having many digital friends can become a defence against feeling lonely, however it does not mitigate the internal loneliness. On the other hand, one cannot have any digital friends, and have a few friends who they have deep connections and meaningful relationships with.

As highlighted above, loneliness refers to a state of feeling emotionally disconnected or isolated from others, even when surrounded by people. It is a subjective feeling of being alone, regardless of physical proximity to others. Loneliness can be a result of lacking meaningful relationships, social support, or a sense of belonging. This can be a real issue if one is othered due to their gender, sexuality, race, class and other social factors. It can also be very present when one emigrates to a new country or moves to a new place where they are a minority and don’t feel that they belong.

On the other hand, being alone simply means being in a state of solitude or not being in the presence of others. Being alone can be a choice or preference, and it does not necessarily imply feelings of loneliness. Many people enjoy spending time alone and find it rejuvenating or peaceful, while others feel lonely due to lack of connections.

In short, loneliness is an emotional state characterized by a sense of isolation and disconnection, while being alone refers to the physical and state of not being with others. One can feel lonely even when surrounded by people, and conversely, one can be alone but not feel lonely.


Loneliness: A silent pandemic 

In my role as a therapist, one of the key complaints l hear in my practice is people who are experiencing profound loneliness, which often develops into depression and anxiety, or perpetuates it. The Office of National Statistics (ONS) reports that one in six adults suffer from moderate to severe depression; these numbers have risen since the pandemic which isolated many people from their loved ones and support networks due to the lockdowns.

Although we are out of the pandemic, we are still haunted by the effects of it which lingers today-poor mental health is one of them. Psychiatrists, GPs, and other prescribers are not keen on enquiring about the social context behind anxiety and depression, yet loneliness is often a big factor in anxiety and depression presentations. Their focus is on symptomology-a medical approach based on assessing whether one meets the diagnostic criteria for depression or anxiety, which often co-exist. If one does, they will be prescribed antidepressants or anti anxiety medication. The NHS England reports that in England alone, a staggering 8.6 million people was prescribed antidepressants between 2022-23.

Taking a psychosocial approach to depression and anxiety, a key precipitant of depression and anxiety is loneliness and stress. Stress is often exacerbated by poor or lack of support. Loneliness happens when one lives a life where there is no emotional connection with others- a combination of stress and loneliness is a catalyst for anxiety and depression.

From my experience as a therapist, loneliness affects everyone; however, it is appears to be more prevalent in people who are not in relationships (single/divorced/widowed), older adults, introverts, people who live away from their primary home, and notoriously so in people who have extremely busy lives that seem to be full lives, but not making time for themselves or others. The later are likely to have many friends, yet they feel lonely. Some people in this category have thousands (even millions) of followers and friends on social media, yet they feel lonely. So why this contradiction? Digital connections are not real connections, the digital world is an illusory realm where relationships s are defined by liking each other’s pictures and statuses, not really knowing each other deeply.

Loneliness is behind the surge in alcoholism, and problematic narcotic use. People who feel lonely are more likely to develop alcohol dependency or habitual substance misuse as a way of coping with loneliness. From an attachment perspective, (Bowlby, 1969) this could be viewed as one having a disorganised/insecure attachment with something they can control, to compensate for the healthy/secure attachment they could have with humans. If one is able to develop a secure attachment with others, and not feel lonely, they are likely not to rely on alcohol or illicit substances.

Alcohol does lead to poor mental health, and can worsen symptoms of anxiety and depression as well as cause insomnia. Poor physical health related to alcohol includes the more severe related alcohol related diseases such as liver cirrhosis or Korsakoff Syndrome (dementia). Alcohol and drug misuse is also linked to higher incidences of domestic violence, risk behaviuors such as drink driving, and suicide.


Benefits of digital platforms

While the online and digital interactions have their disadvantages which feeds into loneliness, they also have some positives. Online connections can be beneficial in widening the reach of people in different parts of the world, and easy interactions through the platform instead of letters, emails, phone calls or face to face. This can be of huge significance to people who may have emigrated to parts of the world where they are disconnected from friends or getting people of a common purpose together for example University or class alumnis.

The online platforms can also enhance one’s self-esteem, especially for people who experience social anxiety, and find face-to-face interactions challenging. The distance in online platform can allow some people to express themselves more fully, something they may not be able to do in the real world.

Humans as social beings

We are social beings at the core, and bonding in real time is key. We seek social connections and thrive by being in the company of others. Human contact releases oxytocin, an anti-stress and “love” hormone- that’s why we are drawn to smiling at a stranger across the room, or hugging our friends when we meet. We have an innate desire for connection through touch and social interaction.

Solitude goes against our human nature. That’s why the NICE guidelines for depression emphasises on behavioural activation, which is fundamentally engaging in positive social activities, that enhances one’s mood and activates emotional states. Isolation and lack of social stimulation is viewed as contributing factors to depression and anxiety. Social interactions and engaging in social activities releases dopamine which is a “feel good” hormone, essential for our physical and mental health.

Our ancestors thrived by living in communities and connections was a therapeutic part of their survival as groups of people who didn’t have sophisticated mental and physical health care systems. They took care of each other and made sure if one is sick, they go back into the cave and get looked after by the elders who told them stories and nursed them to health. However, the world we live in right is very individualistic -each man for himself, and God for us all. This is harmful and a big source of loneliness as individualism leads to people believing that they cannot rely on others but themselves. We have been socially conditioned to believe that asking for help is a sign of weakness; hence why many people feel even lonelier and experience stress through dealing with challenging situations alone.


Factors behind loneliness in the 21st Century

Technology and social media

While technology has made it easier to connect with others, it has also led to increased feelings of loneliness. Many people spend excessive amounts of time on social media, which can create a sense of isolation as they compare their lives to others and feel left out.

Changing social structures

The traditional family structure has evolved, with more people living alone or away from their families. This can lead to increased feelings of isolation and loneliness, especially for older adults who may have limited social connections.

Urbanization and mobility

With the rise of urbanization and increased mobility, people often move away from their hometowns and leave behind established social networks. It can be challenging to build new relationships in unfamiliar environments, leading to feelings of loneliness.

Busy and demanding lifestyles

Modern life is often fast-paced and demanding, leaving little time for socializing and building meaningful connections. Work pressures, long commutes, and constant busyness can contribute to a lack of social interaction, leading to loneliness.

Mental health issues

Loneliness can also be a symptom or result of underlying mental health issues such as depression, anxiety, or social anxiety disorder. These conditions can make it difficult for individuals to engage in social activities and form connections.

Ageing population

As the population ages, older adults may face increased loneliness due to factors such as retirement, loss of friends or loved ones, and limited mobility. Age-related health issues can also contribute to social isolation.


How to cope with loneliness 

It is important to note that loneliness is a complex issue with multiple causes, and the specific reasons may vary from person to person. Addressing loneliness requires a multi-faceted approach that includes improving social connections, fostering community, and promoting mental well-being.

  1. Build and maintain strong relationships. Invest time and effort in building and nurturing close relationships with family, friends, and loved ones. Regularly communicate and spend quality time with them.
  2. Join social groups or clubs. Participate in activities or join clubs that align with your values, interests or hobbies. This can help you meet like-minded individuals and create new friendships and connections.
  3. Volunteer or get involved in your community. Engaging in community service or volunteering not only gives you a sense of purpose but also presents opportunities to meet new people and make connections. Try new things- explore local charities, organisations and clubs.
  4. Adopt a pet. Having a pet can provide companionship and alleviate feelings of loneliness. Pets can offer unconditional love and be a source of comfort and support. Pets can also give us a sense of purpose- being able to look after and nurture a an animal can be rewarding and help create meaning.
  5. Engage in hobbies or activities you enjoy. Pursue activities that you genuinely enjoy, such as painting, playing an instrument, gardening, or reading. This not only helps you spend quality time but may also connect you with others who share similar interests.
  6. Stay active and exercise regularly. Regular physical activity can boost your mood and overall well-being. Consider joining a gym, taking fitness classes, or participating in sports activities, where you can interact with others and potentially make new friends.
  7. Practice self-care. Take care of your physical and mental well-being by practicing self-care activities. This can include getting enough sleep, eating a balanced diet, practicing relaxation techniques, and engaging in activities that promote self-reflection and personal growth.
  8. Use technology minimally to connect and make time for face-to-face interactions. Utilize social media platforms, online communities, and video calling apps to stay connected with friends and family, especially if distance is a barrier. Make time to meet friends and families face to face instead of relying on social medial or text messages.
  9. Embrace solitude. Expand your window of tolerance and capacity to be alone: While it’s important to avoid chronic loneliness, it’s equally important to learn how to be comfortable with solitude. Without doing so, we might end up in the wrong company to avoid being alone. Engage in activities that you enjoy alone, such as reading, taking nature walks, or practicing mindfulness, can help you appreciate and enjoy your own company.
  10. Seek professional help if needed. If you are struggling with chronic loneliness, suffer from social anxiety or feel isolated, seek support from an accredited therapist. Therapists can provide guidance and strategies to cope with loneliness, improve social connections and address any underlying reasons why one may be feeling lonely in the company of others.

References

Bowlby, J. (1969) Attachment and Loss: Volume 1. Basic Books. New York,

Winnicott, D.W. (1958) The Capacity to be alone. International Journal of Psychoanalysis, 39: 416-420

Image Credit to Elijah Hiett-Unsplash

Categories
Uncategorized

Why do l wish you a Gentle Christmas, not a Merry Christmas?

COPYRIGHT CITY SANCTUARY THERAPY

No part of this website, including the blog content may be copied, duplicated or reproduced in any manner without the author’s permission.

 

Any information, materials, and opinions on this blog do not constitute therapy or professional advice. If you need professional help, please contact a qualified mental health practitioner

 

 

 

Why do I wish you a Gentle Christmas, not a Merry Christmas.

 

Why does wishing some people a merry Christmas emotionally injurious?

Why does calling the Christmas period a “festive season” an arbitrary notion.

 

Our society has always framed the Christmas period as a time of festivities, celebrations, family gatherings, gifting, merry, and cheer. Why is this social construct harmful and problematic?  It is indeed problematic because for many, the Christmas period is not a joyous time, but a time of intense loneliness, sadness, grief, mourning, and sorrow. It is a time where many people are painfully reminded of their losses, be it through death, separation, estrangement, and other unique life circumstances.

 

Unlike other forms of losses, there are many people who will spend the festive period alone, or away from their families, as they have made the brave decision to distance themselves from toxic families, friends, or unhealthy dynamics, in order to protect their mental health and peace. Some have divorced or ended unhealthy relationships, while others have had their relationships ended by their ex-partners. For others, migration has disconnected them from their families and friends. Many are bidding farewell to their loved ones who have terminal illnesses.  The ravaging wars have directly impacted many others; they have family and friends stuck in the war zones, and therefore acutely worried about their wellbeing and safety. Surely Christmas is far from being a joyous period, but a time of pain, sorrow, and aguish.

 

Capitalism and the erasure of Christmas

We live in a capitalist world where there is an erasure of the true essence of Christmas. Christmas has become a vanity affair, a time to buy each other expensive gifts. Real love is not shown through deeds, but extravagant Christmas gifts, and lavish Christmas parties. This is problematic as some people who may not have the financial means to buy gifts for their loved ones are put under immense pressure and often left experiencing a lot of shame for not “providing” in the ways that others are seen to be. People who are estranged from their families are likely not to receive any cards, gifts, or invitation from their families. Wishing someone in this category a merry Christmas is indeed poking a sore wound. Wishing them a gentle Xmas is a more meaningful, and truly compassionate way of acknowledging that we all have unique circumstances, which shapes how we view and experience the Christmas period. It is not always joyous and that is ok!

 

Christmas and the impending New Year

The Christmas week is only a week away from the new year. The calendar date changes spell the ending of an era, a time of loss, and letting go of the old year- paradoxically there is a fusion of time and space, in the separation of the old and new.  The Christmas and New year periods are indeed  contemplative ones, where many people reflect on the year, and make an appraisal of their experiences and milestones.  Some may have struggled relationally, financially, emotionally, spiritually, and with their mental health- it is a time of acknowledging and accepting what was, and making plans of what could be.  The awareness of failures or shortfalls can provoke anxiety, sadness, and other complex feelings such as shame, anger, guilt, self-blame and even self-loathing. New year resolutions are often made from a place of wanting to make up for these shortfalls.

 

Mental Health Crises during the Festive Period

The mental health services report a higher rate of people experiencing mental health crises over the Christmas period. Indeed, psychiatric admissions are on the high, and calls to Samaritans, and other telephone helpline services soar- these are from people who are finding it difficult to go through Christmas. This highlights the issue that Christmas is not always a joyous time, and it is a time where many are pushed beyond their capacity to cope. Mental Health UK reports that 54% of the population find the Christmas period stressful and emotionally challenging. A Yougov survey revealed that a quarter of the UK population agree that Christmas makes their mental health worse.

 

For people with social anxiety and generalised anxiety, family pressures to attend big gatherings can be very stressful and exacerbate their anxiety. This can have long lasting impact of them, beyond the Christmas period. Anxiety puts the body’s nervous system into fight, flight, or freeze modes. Staying in any of these modes for extended periods of time can indeed put a strain on the body’s nervous system and also cause wear and tear, leading to depression, which often co-exist with anxiety. Anxiety can impair one’s ability to cope with day-to-day life, and if left untreated, it can have enduring and severe consequences on one’s overall wellbeing.

 

For many, the Christmas period can trigger stress and anxiety. The idea of being a perfect host and having a perfect Christmas can also present with a cluster of secondary challenges. Some parents feel pressured to be great mothers/fathers for their children and make a perfect Christmas for them. Instead of Christmas being celebratory, it becomes a time of heightened anxiety, stress, and conflict as well.

 

Christmas Timing- Seasonal Mood Changes

The Christmas period is at the peak of the winter season; December is the month with less daylight and wettest weather. The Winter solstice is on the 22nd December; we have only about 7 and a half hours of daylight.

The winter period is in itself a challenging time, for many people who are likely to experience seasonal affective mood changes. Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD) and anxiety is high during the winter seasons. The stress around the Christmas period can exacerbate what is already fragile mental health. Mind UK reports that a third of the population experiences seasonal mood changes. This demonstrates how Christmas can be even more challenging to some in a period that is already difficult for them.

 

Boundaries and Family Gatherings

Many people find family gatherings stressful and daunting due to family members’ lack of boundaries- offering unsolicited advice, asking why one isn’t married or have kids yet,  body shaming, and querying one’s sexuality.  In today’s society, many people are choosing to delay marriage & having kids, and others make conscious decisions not to. Many people are in same sex relationships or non monogamous unconventional relationships.  Christmas is a period where family gatherings bring with it a lot of stress of having to defend oneself or justify their life decisions. Christmas does indeed become a dreadful period which require tact and tenacity to navigate.

 

As a society we have come obsessed with slim figures, devaluing the fact that we all come in different shapes, sizes, and BMI. Some people are naturally slimmer than others; while some find it harder to shift body weight than others. The notion that slim is healthy, desirable, and attractive, inadvertently normalises body shaming in families. Not having seen each other for long periods of time often invites comments about weight gain, weight loss-body shaming, and other inappropriate pernicious behaviours.

 

Domestic Violence

It is known that domestic violence is on the high during the festive period and this is the case for many reasons. People have easier access to alcohol as drinking during the Christmas is normalised. People are likely to drink more, or binge, and they are likely to have less outdoor activities due to the poor weather conditions.  Financial pressures become apparent over the Christmas period & they tend to become a source of conflict for many couples, leading to fights. The social pressures to get everything together for Christmas also present its challenges which can significantly escalate into domestic abuse- verbal, emotional, and physical. The National Domestic Helpline reports that domestic violence is high during Christmas period with the number of call domestic violence reacted calls multiply over the festive period. It is known that there is a correlation between domestic abuse, poverty and crime.

 

*Reframing a merry Christmas into a gentle Christmas means we can approach Christmas mindful of those whose circumstances does not make this period particularly pleasant. For those who struggle during Christmas, they can embrace Christmas for what it is, and what it brings, and lean into the feelings, whether it’s, sadness, grief and reflection, without feeling the pressure to pretend all is ok, just because its Christmas*

 

Ways to support each other over the Christmas Period

-Check in with friends and family even if it means dropping them a line

-If you are estranged from your biological family, develop relationships with others (chosen families) that you can spend time with and celebrate important events like Christmas with

-Send cards to others, you never know what a difference it makes to someone who may not have anyone extending love to them in that way

-If you find Christmas gathering difficult, politely decline invitations and spend your Christmas wherever you feel safe

-If you have family members who often give unsolicited advice, create boundaries by politely asking them not to offer the advice

-If you are prone to getting stressed over Xmas, plan your days in advance and create small and manageable tasks that you can approach in a systematic way

– If you are prone to drinking over Xmas, be mindful of the amount of alcohol you jut & consume. Limiting access to alcohol means you are less likely to binge

-If you are a victim of domestic violence, seek help from family and friends or call the National Domestic Abuse Helpline

– Instead of wishing others a merry Xmas, wish them a gentle Christmas instead.

 

May you step into 2024 extending love, kindness, and compassion to others around you.

Love is the whole thing, we are only pieces -Rumi!

Photo Credit Jemima-Whyles Unsplash

Categories
Uncategorized

How to Cope with Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD) – Winter Depression

COPYRIGHT CITY SANCTUARY THERAPY

No part of this website, including the blog content may be copied, duplicated or reproduced in any manner without the author’s permission.

 

Any information, materials, and opinions on this blog do not constitute therapy or professional advice. If you need professional help, please contact a qualified mental health practitioner.

 

Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD) – Winter Depression

For many people, the onset of autumn and winter seasons also spell the beginning of long depressive episodes, that only lift in the spring or the beginning of summer. The acronym SAD -seasonal affective disorder- does indeed highlight what winter months are like for many who are prone to seasonal changes in mood.

Winter depression is as a form of depression that typically manifest during the cold winter seasons, and resolves in the warmer months. People who live in climates with distinctive differences in seasonal weathers are likely to experience SAD, than those who live in warmer climates, with warmer winters.

 

Changes in weather – damp and cold, days – less daylight, shorter days and longer nights- and less stimulation, where people are less likely to spend time outdoors are some the underlying factors that provoke, or heighten SAD.

 

For some people, the depressive pattern is cyclic over years, and it can impair one’s functioning during the winter months when they are depressed. SAD can be severe enough to require treatment with medication and or therapy. However, self-care is crucial in the management of SAD- to minimise the risk of developing winter depression, and minimising the risk of SAD becoming more severe.

 

Winter depression has all the hallmarks of normal depression such as:

  • Low mood
  • Loss of interest
  • Poor appetite
  • Apathy- lack of interest
  • Lethargy- lack of energy
  • Low libido
  • Increased appetite/loss of appetite
  • Difficulty concentrating
  • Irritability and mood swings
  • Sleep disturbances

 

For many people who suffer from winter depression, cravings for sweets and sugary foods is another symptom they have to cope with. If not, one tends to comfort eat as a way of soothing the low mood. However, the side effects for this is weight gain, which does feeds into self-esteem and poor self-image- depression-self loathing.

The wet and cold weather make it more challenging to spend time outdoors, or exercise in the same way as people do in the warm summer weather. This exacerbates weight gain. For many people it take months to shift this weight over the summer months; however, as soon as the winter starts, they go back into the same cycle.

 

Causes of SAD

Winter depression is poorly understood. However, there is a link to the production of serotonin which is depleted due to the lack of sunshine (vitamin D) in the winter. Vitamin D is essential to the body’s natural function and to our well being overall. It helps the body build bones, muscle, and tissue reparation,  and it is key to skin health. It also helps with building a stronger immune system which is key in  fighting germs and other harmful bacteria. High levels of melatonin which affects sleep has also been linked to winter depression.

 

For those who are prone to wonder depression, there are many ways to look after yourself during the winter months, and beat the winter blues!

 

Here are some of the tips:

 

  • Make some lifestyle changes- diet, exercise and sleep
  • Have a routine where are you don’t spend all day indoors
  • Maintain a healthy diet
  • Have a dose of vitamin D when you can-catch the sun light when the sun is out- sunbath
  • Eat foods high in vitamin D such as oily fish, egg yolks, red meat, and liver
  • Curb any cravings for sugary and sweet foods by eating other healthier alternatives such as fruit
  • Go out for walks when there is daylight
  • Spend time around family, friends, and other people
  • Join a sports club if you can, where you can do at indoors activities
  • Meal preparation is helpful to keep on top of unhealthy eating patterns or stress eating
  • Exercise sleep hygiene and have a routine in your sleep
  • Use a SAD Lamp therapy-solar light that produces bright light as a supplement of sunlight vitamin D
  • Avoid spending loads of time watching negative news on social media. Absorbing the negative content can have a negative impact on your mental health overall
  • Prioritise fluids and drink plenty of water
  • Drink less alcohol
  • Go on holiday somewhere warm to break the winter if you can
  • Spend time away from gadgets and walk in nature
  • Keep a journal and jot your daily reflections to track your progress
  • Take Vitamin D supplements
  • See a therapist if you think your depression is not improving over time

Image Credit to: Fons Heijnsbroek

 

 

Categories
Uncategorized

Navigating University life and mental health: Tips for students and parents

COPYRIGHT CITY SANCTUARY THERAPY

No part of this website, including the blog content may be copied, duplicated or reproduced in any manner without the author’s permission.

 

Any information, materials, and opinions on this blog do not constitute therapy or professional advice. If you need professional help, please contact a qualified mental health practitioner.

Dr Joyline Gozho, Adult Psychotherapist (Individual & Couples) FPC, UKCP, NCPS

The academic year is about to begin; many young adults will be leaving their family homes to start a new life at university. For many, this will be the very first of them leaving home (their nest) for an extended period, spending time away from their families, and social networks.

Image

While this is an exciting time for these young adults, and parents seeing their children transition into higher education and gain independence, it is also a very vulnerable time for many. Some students struggle with the stress, separation, and adjusting to a new life away from home, which puts them at high risk of developing mental health problems.

These difficulties can at times get quite severe necessitating them to pause their studies or drop out. Some will continue their studies while receiving help, support, and treatment for their mental health.


Life stages and childhood – adulthood transition

The adolescent stage where most students are when they start university is indeed a crisis stage, where the child transitions into adulthood. This is not an event, but a process which takes time, with the adolescent oscillating between childlike states and tendencies, to being an adult who is able to look after themselves, and gain a sense of independence.

Many students who start university education are likely to be in their late teens -adolescents – or in their early twenties. These are not fully adults. Despite looking mature physically and outwardly, there are a lot of changes happening internally, pivoted by the surge of hormones. They are at a stage where they are learning a lot about adult life, exploring sexuality, and taking on an adult identity.

While the adolescent may have met all the developmental milestones physically and intellectually, it is important to keep in mind that they also have to meet the developmental milestones psychosexually and attain certain psychological abilities. It is indeed in the adolescent stage where personality and identity are formed; the child becomes an adult who has a solid sense of self and is autonomous in the world that they live with others.

The child also severs their dependence on adults – the parents – and develops into an adult, forming adult-to-adult relationships, instead of adult-child relationships. The negotiation between the outer and inner worlds can present a crisis to the adolescent and their parents, who are intrinsically part of this process. Some of the rebellious behaviours, the pushing of boundaries, and sexual exploration are all part of the negotiation, and identity formation.

Parents play a critical role in this tumultuous stage, where their presence and consistency in holding the adolescent through this transitionary phase is paramount. This stage is very critical, and it needs to be navigated very delicately, with parents being the moderator of what is acceptable and not.

Some young adults may not experience a smooth transition into adulthood and will see the emergence of mental health challenges including depression anxiety, self-harm, and eating disorders. Leaving home to start university can disrupt this already delicate process, making some students vulnerable to developing mental health problems during their time at university, away from their parents.


Attachments and loss

Leaving home, a familiar environment, means disconnecting from primary attachment figures (loss) – family, friends, home, etc. This spells a breakdown of emotional bonds the student would have built with their significant others and their environment. We may not see this as an attachment injury, however, this loss also means the student has to deal with absence and grieve for the loss of the significant attachments while fostering new connections in a foreign environment.

This loss can be profound for some students who become completely disconnected from their families, friends, support networks, and everything that is familiar to them. These are students who may have to move countries, cities etc. where there is not only an unfamiliar environment, but unfamiliar weather, climate, food, language etc. Foreign students and students who live far away from their homes often experience this loss more deeply than the ones who can visit home easily. However, this does not mean they do not experience loss in the same way.

Another form of loss experienced during the stage students start university is a loss of the old self – the child – and coming to terms with the new identity as an adult. This loss can stimulate ambivalent feelings about adulthood – while it brings a new sense of freedom, independence, and autonomy, being an autonomous and independent adult can be challenging – growing pains. Indeed, it comes with its own challenges of having to navigate everyday life without the watchful eyes of the parents and having to develop new relationships in an alien environment.


University culture – small fish in a big pond phenomenon

Many students who end up going to university are likely to have been academically superior, and popular in their former schools. They may have enjoyed the success of being in the top sets in their classes. When they start university, they realise they are just one of many others who are just as capable. There is often a lot of competition among university students, which can trigger a sense of being inadequate or being not as smart as the next person.

The rigorous nature of university studies, and the competencies they are expected to meet fuels this competition, which often becomes unhealthy, leading to anxiety and imposter syndrome. Many students find that they suddenly feel very small when they have always felt powerful; this creates a real blow to their confidence and self-esteem.

These secondary issues have a huge impact on their mental health, and how they navigate their new life at University. The newfound freedom and absence/loss of parental figures who keep a close eye on them can also lead to substance and alcohol misuse as a way of coping. This has a huge impact on one’s mental health.

Many students struggle with stress and coping with juggling their studies, academic life, social life, and independent living. It is not unusual for some students to end up experiencing severe mental health problems that require treatment from mental health professionals. At times parents have to be involved to support the students and keep a closer eye on them. In worst-case scenarios the students may end up deferring their studies, leaving University. This is indeed very sad and painful for the students and their parents.


Tips for students and parents to cope with University life

It is not unusual for students to struggle with their mental health in the first years of starting university. If you feel that you are one of them, here are the self-care tips to keep your mental health at an optimal level:

  • Have a routine and prioritise rest from the library, classes, lab etc.
  • Maintain a healthy and balanced diet, do not rely on takeaways-make your own meals.
  • Make sure you get enough sleep and exercise sleep hygiene.
  • Build a staple group of friends who are mutually supportive.
  • Join University clubs and other social clubs so you can spend time with other people.
  • Do not isolate yourself – make new connections and seek out new hobbies.
  • Do not compete with your peers. We are all different – be mindful of the small fish in a pond phenomenon!
  • Be mindful of peer pressure and how easy it is to lose focus. Peer pressure encompasses partying, drug use, truancy, and other delinquent behaviours.
  • Maintain a positive relationship with your tutor where you can share your worries, concerns and anxieties.
  • Stay in touch with your family and friends back home.
  • Register with a local GP.
  • Identify your University student counselling service and investigate the referral process.
  • Self-refer to the student counselling services if you feel that your mental health is deteriorating.
  • If you have a history of mental illness, identify your local CMHT and CRT.
  • Parents – keep an eye on your children and try and have an open channel of communication.
  • Parents – visit your children and make sure they are settling in well, and be curious about their new life.
  • Do not ignore any signs of acopia or unusual behaviours, for example not answering phones etc.

Counselling Directory is not responsible for the articles published by members. The views expressed are those of the member who wrote the article.

Image
London SE1 & Milton Keynes MK15
Written
Image: Credit to Trishal Virsha
Categories
Uncategorized

Sibling rivalry: Navigating unhealthy sibling relationships

COPYRIGHT CITY SANCTUARY THERAPY

No part of this website, including the blog content may be copied, duplicated or reproduced in any manner without the author’s permission.

 

Any information, materials, and opinions on this blog do not constitute therapy or professional advice. If you need professional help, please contact a qualified mental health practitioner.

Sibling rivalry: Navigating unhealthy sibling relationships

For some people, relationships with their siblings, which are meant to be loving, caring, nurturing, and fulfilling, are a source of great pain and anguish. You share so much history, the same genetic makeup, you share the same parents (or parent), you made so many memories together – good and bad. There is just so much to reflect on and laugh about; what really goes wrong for this unique relationship to become so adversarial?

Image

Rivalry and conflict between siblings are more common than is talked about. As a society, there seems to be reticence to accept it exists, yet it is at the core of my people’s suffering in life. This may be because when sibling rivalry is talked about, it stimulates some powerful feelings, including shame, guilt, blame, anger, defensiveness, sadness and fear.

In some families, there is often a desire to maintain a united front or a façade, while harbouring so much resentment towards each other. In other families, the rivalry turns into an all-out war, dragging others into it, creating an “us and them”. This muteness in not acknowledging sibling rivalry, viewing it as taboo, and not openly addressing it means many people go through life carrying many unseen and deep emotional scars, due to the relationship challenges they have endured, and the emotional damage caused by their own siblings. It is only in therapy that many get to learn to speak about it, and feel safe to do so, without judgment or the fear of being seen as the” troublemaker”.

Having recently read Prince Harry’s memoir Spare, it is clear that the running theme throughout this book is that of rivalry between him and his older sibling, and his feelings of growing up experiencing himself as the “spare”, the second best, the auxiliary. In the public eye, these are boys, now men, who have always been seen as close, united, and the model version of perfect brotherhood. This highlights how prevalent sibling rivalry is; it touches on every family regardless of race, social class, gender, ethnicity and culture.

When there is a perception that parents give one child preferential treatment, or if there is real evidence that the parents are favouring a particular child over the other, it often creates conflict, fuelled by jealousy and envy. Underneath the jealousy and envy are more complex feelings – anger, shame, guilt, sadness, grief, and resentment.

For the subject, there is often a sense of being deprived of something of huge significance (love, affection, attention, nurturance) that was made abundantly available to the other sibling/s. If the experiences that are deemed to be favouritism, or preferential treatment by the parents are not addressed, it can lead to deep-seated feelings of resentment towards siblings, which can breed throughout life.


What lies behind sibling rivalry

Sibling rivalry often originates from very early on in life, and it is fundamentally shaped by some underlying factors and unconscious processes. In some cases, the rivalry creates conflict that is difficult to mend, leading to ongoing relationship tensions between siblings. Here are some of the causes of sibling rivalry.

Birth order

Firstborn

We are competitive beings; it made us survive through generations where the unfit perished and the fittest thrived. Competition is healthy, and it also happens between siblings, even though we may not be conscious of it. It is however the nature and degree of it which determines whether it is healthy or unhealthy. Despite being born to the same parents, each child is a unique entity in a family, which has its own set of needs, and developmental journey to make.

One’s personality is built through a combination of many factors, the key one being how they experience their relationship with their parents. The proximity to parents, and age difference, can have a huge influence on the perceptions each sibling creates on how they are being treated. We all thrive when we feel loved, cared for, prioritised and we feel seen. However, if one sibling is always towering over the other, the child who is behind is often left feeling unseen and unheard, despite the parent’s efforts – this stimulates competition.

This is common in families where the firstborn tends to become a surrogate parent and, therefore, is seen as the one who gets more attention and exercises authority over the younger siblings. The firstborn child may be experienced by the younger siblings as harsh, controlling and powerful. It is a fact that the first-born child already had an established relationship with the parents before the younger siblings were born. The arrival of a younger sibling/s may stimulate jealousy, and envy, in the firstborn, and being replaced, therefore getting less of the parent’s attention.

The firstborn may also experience the parents as harsher on them, as they tend to be more forceful and robust in channelling the first child to success in life. This can stimulate a range of feelings in the subject – anger, frustration, guilt, strife to please the parents. The younger siblings may also perceive this as the parents giving the older sibling more attention, deeply impacting their relationship with the older sibling. All these factors, which may be unconscious, are foundational in the genesis of sibling rivalry.

Last born 

The last-born child is often seen as the baby of the family and tends to be viewed as the one who gets special treatment. By the time the last sibling is born, it is true that most parents would have become more competent, and confident in their parenting skills, and would have developed their unique parenting style. They tend to be more relaxed and less cautious, which can stimulate feelings of jealousy and envy from other siblings who may have experienced the parents as being harsher and harder on them.

The younger sibling is likely to remain home with the parents, while the older siblings leave home to start university or work. This also means they get to spend more quality time with their parents, which other siblings may not have experienced. This can be a source of jealousy and anger towards the younger sibling from the older siblings for being denied the same level of relaxed and due attention.

Middle child

The middle child syndrome is undeniable – it is often the middle child who feels unseen and unheard in a family. The first siblings get special attention, the youngest child gets a different type of attention as the baby of the family, while the middle child is often left boxed in these two powerful juxtapositions, deprived of attention.

The middle child tends to develop mechanisms to get attention from the parents, at times through academic excellence, looking after the parents, or just being the good child who doesn’t cause the parents any trouble. This can also mean the middle child not psychologically developing in the same way as other siblings who get the parents’ full attention, as they have to mould their needs around others.

Growing up in this position can in later life stimulate feelings of being unloved, and the need to look after everyone else in order to get attention and love. These middle children can also easily become servitude to their other siblings in order to seek to gain their attention and approval. This learned behaviour and internalised way of relating is carried into adult life. Experiencing the other siblings being favoured can be a source of jealousy, and provoke a need to put oneself as secondary in later life.

Gender

In some families, the children’s gender determines how they are treated by the parents and other siblings. This is most common in BAME and other minority communities where boys – sons – are seen as tokens in the family, and daughters are viewed as less than, secondary. These unspoken notions are not often explicitly voiced, yet they are powerfully felt.

Daughters are seen as liabilities, and they do not hold the family legacy in the same way as sons do. Some first-born daughters therefore feel the need to strive in life in order to match up the parents’ expectations of a son. Brothers who are in second and third place can also end up feeling competitive and rivalrous towards older sisters. If the son is the first child, daughters who come second are often treated less favourably. Parents’ own projection play a big part in how the children relate to each other. Unchecked this can be a source of huge rivalry and conflict in families.

Parentification as a contradiction

Parentification is when the child is given duties and responsibilities that are not age-appropriate. Parentification can occur in two different forms – emotional and instrumental. Some people may experience one of the other, while others experience both.

Emotional parentification is when the child provides emotional support to the adult, while instrumental parentification is when the adult assigns and ascribes adult roles and duties to the child. In practice, the adult may simply offload on the child, confide, ask questions, and seek advice from the child. It can also happen when a child is given adult chores, that are not age appropriate. When this happens, there is a role reversal where the child becomes the adult, the provider of emotional containment to an adult, and an involuntary provider of practical support.

Many a time parentification happens covertly, and the adult may not recognise their emotional and practical dependence on the child. In any situation where there is emotional parentification, there is neither a sensor in the adult nor a recognition of boundaries of what is appropriate to share, how much can be shared with the child and what is and isn’t age-appropriate. Children do not only grow and develop physically, but they also develop psychologically and have certain milestones they need to reach and accomplish. Parentification interferes with the natural development of the child, and accomplishing their own developmental tasks, as they are pivoted into adulthood.

It is not unusual for parents to have a close relationship with a particular child, at certain stages in life, or throughout life. In most families, it is the oldest or youngest sibling. When there is instrumental parentification, it is typically the oldest child who becomes the surrogate parent or the one to whom the parents offload all their troubles. The conundrum is that this may be experienced as a form of closeness with the parents that other children do not share, yet it is indeed a form of emotional abuse-parentification.

In some families, the youngest sibling, the one who leaves home later than everyone else, becomes the parent’s confidant and handyman. Where parents have relationship challenges, or separation/divorce, this child is left bearing a lot of the parents’ own struggles. Again from the outside, this may be a sign of closeness, which stimulates jealousy and envy from other siblings, internally it may not be the same, there is a contradiction.

Trauma

At times parents may have closer relationships with a particular child than the others due to the child’s developmental journey. When there is developmental trauma for example sickness, disease, disability or some form of injury, accident etc. the parents tend to pay a close eye on that sibling and develop a closer relationship. Temperament from birth, how smoothly the child reached their developmental milestones, and academic and intellectual abilities also determine the quality of relationships the parents develop with the child.

The parents may become overprotective, cautious, and more careful when dealing with a child who is seen as vulnerable than not. This response to trauma can indeed impact the relationship between the other siblings who may feel deprived of the same level of attention developed with the particular child who had a traumatic or challenging upbringing. In other families, it is the brighter child who gets more attention from the parents, overshadowing the not-so-bright siblings. This can also be a source of conflict and rivalry.

Narcissistic parents, generational traumas, and transference

We often forget that parents were children once upon a time, and they remain children at the very core. Despite being physically mature, psychologically, parents may be still growing, and have a lot of psychological maturing to do. No one has a manual or tool kit on parenting; parents learn to parent on the job, and they learn from mistakes. Parents can see themselves in their own children, as they were children themselves once upon a time. It is not unusual for parents to unconsciously project their own unmet needs onto their children, thereby stimulating or fuelling rivalry between them.

Sibling rivalry is common in dysfunctional families. The dysfunction lies in the parents, in their own conflicts, their unmet childhood needs, and how they were parented – it has a generational constellation. Parents who are “narcissistic” are unable to accept responsibility for their own failures or insecurities, they risk having a narcissistic psychic collapse. It is often the case that the drama that the children unconsciously play out is on behalf of the parents who are not able to confront their own traumas and address their own unmet needs from their childhood.

For example, a mother who felt unloved by her own mother can develop a perverse relationship with her daughter where she lives vicariously through her – there are no boundaries and she will do anything to make sure that child is given special treatment over others. Another example is a father who may have had a harsh father himself; he either becomes very harsh towards his own son/s, or too relaxed and unboundaried to the detriment of his relationships with other siblings.

A parent or parents may like a child who reminds them of a past figure grandparent etc. or resent them for the same depending on the type of relationship with that lost person. This is a transference, a way of relating that is based on an internalised early figure. If it is a negative transference, the child is treated favourably and if it is a negative transference, parents can become very harsh towards that child as they remind them of an early life figure.

Freud (1913) described transference as an unconscious phenomenon that is omnipresent in relationships we create with others; it is an act of projecting an internal experience into the external world. With this unconscious drama being played out, rivalry breeds, with the parents being the creators and choreographers. This type of sibling rivalry is very common and most harmful as it often engulfs the whole family with parents taking sides, due to their close identification with one or more of the children. This is a painful place to be, due to the powerful nature of the projections, and how we often act out what is being projected.


Managing an unhealthy relationship with a sibling

If you are someone who has an unhealthy relationship with a sibling, here are some ways to manage it:

  • Maintain a respectful and boundaried relationship with your sibling, don’t force things.
  • Do not compare your sibling relationships with other families. Each family is different, and it comes with its own unique generational traumas.
  • Create healthy relationships with other siblings and family members where you can have mutually nurturing relationships.
  • Be curious and ask your parents stories about their own childhood and life. There is a lot to discover from people’s stories and how they grew up which may explain some of the dynamics.
  • Remind yourself that not having a healthy relationship with a sibling is not a sign of failure, and it doesn’t mean you do not deserve other loving relationships.
  • Consider therapy for you and your sibling if you really want to talk things through in a safe space.
  • Consider family therapy if the sibling rivalry spans into the whole family dynamic. This form of therapy can help you all heal as a family and find the language to describe your experience in a more reflective way without blaming and shaming.
  • Consider individual therapy to address this form of relational trauma. It can be very confusing and unsettling to not feel loved and valued by people who should be closest to us.
  • If you are a first child, try and reflect on the impact of your position and behaviour on your younger siblings, and your relationship with your parents – were you parentified in some way? What is the impact on you?
  • If you are a middle child, reflect on your needs and identify what you consider unmet and how it relates to the way to deal with relationships as an adult.
  • If you are the last-born child, try and reflect on your position and what it meant to you and your siblings.
  • If you are a parent, and you have children in conflict, do reflect on what you are bringing in from your own past. Address it separately, in therapy. That’s an act of love for your children.
Image
London SE1 & Milton Keynes MK15
Written by Dr Joyl